Education Post believes that unduly harsh rhetoric impedes productive conversation. It’s much easier to simply ignore or walk away from someone who calls you names than to thoughtfully engage, let alone actually solve problems.
So we took notice when Condoleezza Rice—former Secretary of State, National Security Advisor and current business professor at Stanford University—equated “racism” with, “Anybody who isn’t in favor of school choice, anybody who isn’t in favor of educational reform, anybody who defends the status quo in the educational system.”
We agree that wealthy people should not be the only ones with choices about where to send their children. For many inner-city parents, public charter schools are the only option.
We assert that opponents of college-readiness standards are essentially condemning low-income children to a second-class education. Low standards will be lowest in high-poverty schools, and these students will be denied the opportunity to successfully pursue college.
We believe the anti-testing movement is partly driven by middle-class families resisting the transparency, accountability and interventions primarily designed to protect our most vulnerable students—low-income children, children of color and students with disabilities.
‘Undeniable Racial Dimensions’
We contend that no one can defend the gaps in achievement, high school graduation, college-readiness and college completion between low-income and higher-income students.
No one can defend the funding inequities that provide extraordinary resources to children of privilege while children with far greater needs make do with less.
So, there are undeniable racial dimensions and inequities to education politics, and some of the people resisting needed change could be categorized as racist.
But some of the people resisting reforms are African-Americans. They might be teachers, parents or community leaders. It’s hard to call them racist.
Some of these opponents raise legitimate concerns about issues like over-testing or low-quality charter schools. Raising honest questions about these issues does not make them racist.
And, some people resisting reform may simply be skeptical of change. Still, it is harsh to label them all as racist just because they don’t share our views. Instead, we should just call them wrong.